Contemporary Ethical Issues in Nursing Related

Review Contemporary Ethical Issues in Nursing related questions and content

The new director of nurses has instituted "walking rounds" on all nursing units, rather than the usual taped shift reports. A veteran nurse exclaims, "She doesn't know how we do things here!" The nurse is demonstrating:

  • A. appeal to emotion.
  • B. appeal to tradition.
  • C. red herring.
  • D. straw man.
Correct Answer: B

Rationale: The correct answer is B: appeal to tradition. The veteran nurse is objecting to the change in practice solely because it deviates from the usual way of doing things. This demonstrates a reliance on tradition rather than considering the potential benefits of the new approach. The appeal to tradition fallacy assumes that something is better or correct simply because it is the traditional way.

Incorrect choices:
A: Appeal to emotion - This choice involves manipulating emotions to win an argument, which is not evident in the scenario.
C: Red herring - This choice involves diverting attention from the real issue, which is not the case in the scenario.
D: Straw man - This choice involves misrepresenting the opponent's argument to make it easier to attack, which is not demonstrated in the scenario.