Critical Care Nursing Questions Related

Review Critical Care Nursing Questions related questions and content

A nurse is on a committee that is trying to reduce the occurrence of hospital-acquired infections in the ICU. Her role is to conduct research to find which interventions have been shown to be most effective in reducing these infections. She consults many different sources and finds conflicting information. Which of the following sources should she consider the most authoritative?

  • A. AACN expert panel report
  • B. A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in the American Journal of Nursing
  • C. A systematic review of qualitative studies in the Journal of Advanced Nursing
  • D. A single randomized controlled trial in the American Journal of Critical Care
Correct Answer: B

Rationale: The correct answer is B: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in the American Journal of Nursing.

1. Meta-analyses provide a comprehensive overview of multiple studies, increasing the reliability of the findings.
2. Randomized controlled trials are considered the gold standard in research design for assessing intervention effectiveness.
3. The American Journal of Nursing is a reputable source in the field of nursing, ensuring the credibility of the study.
4. By synthesizing data from various trials, the meta-analysis can offer a more robust and generalizable conclusion compared to a single trial or qualitative studies.

Incorrect choices:
A: AACN expert panel report - Expert opinions may vary and lack the empirical evidence provided by research studies.
C: A systematic review of qualitative studies in the Journal of Advanced Nursing - Qualitative studies may provide valuable insights but may not offer concrete evidence on intervention effectiveness like quantitative studies.
D: A single randomized controlled trial in the American Journal of Critical Care - Single trials may not capture the full picture and