Critical Care Nursing Practice Questions Related

Review Critical Care Nursing Practice Questions related questions and content

Critical illness often results in family conflicts. Which scenario is most likely to result in the greatest conflict?

  • A. A 21-year-old college student of divorced parents hosp italized with multiple trauma. She resides with her mother. The parents are amicable with each other and have similar values. The father blames the daughter’s b oyfriend for causing the accident.
  • B. A 36-year-old male admitted for a ruptured cerebral an eurysm. He has been living with his 34-year-old girlfriend for 8 years, and they have a 4-year-old daughter. He does not have written advance directives. His parents aarbriribv.ceo mfr/otemst out-of-state and are asked to make decisions about his health care. He h as not seen them in over a year.
  • C. A 58-year-old male admitted for coronary artery bypas s surgery. He has been living with his same-sex partner for 20 years in a committed relationship. He has designated his sister, a registered nurse, as his healthca re proxy in a written advance directive.
  • D. A 78-year-old female admitted with gastrointestinal blaebeirdbi.cnogm./ tHeset r hemoglobin is decreasing to a critical level. She is a Jehovah’s Witness and refuses the treatment of a blood transfusion. She is capable of making her ow n decisions and has a clearly written advance directive declining any transfu sions. Her son is upset with her and tells her she is “committing suicide.”
Correct Answer: D

Rationale: The correct answer is D because it involves a conflict between the patient's autonomy and her son's beliefs. The patient, a Jehovah's Witness, has clearly stated her refusal of a blood transfusion in her advance directive, which aligns with her religious beliefs. Her son's disagreement with her decision creates a significant ethical dilemma and conflict. This scenario highlights the clash between respecting the patient's autonomy and the son's concerns for her well-being.

Choice A is less likely to result in the greatest conflict as both parents have similar values and are amicable, with the conflict being directed towards the daughter's boyfriend.

Choice B involves a conflict between the patient's girlfriend and parents, but the patient's lack of advance directives and estranged relationship with his parents do not present as significant a conflict as in the correct answer.

Choice C involves a designated healthcare proxy and a committed relationship, which are less likely to result in a conflict as compared to the clash of beliefs and autonomy seen in Choice D.