Population Based Health Care Related

Review Population Based Health Care related questions and content

A mother discusses her concerns about genetic transmission of schizophrenia with the nurse saying, 'My son is a fraternal twin. He has been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Will my other son develop schizophrenia, too?' The response that is both sensitive and shows understanding of the genetic component is:

  • A. You poor woman! I wish I could tell you he will be free of the disorder.'
  • B. Studies show that 50% of twins develop schizophrenia when it is present in the other twin.'
  • C. No one can say what will happen, so we will hope for the best for you and your sons.'
  • D. In fraternal twins, the chance of the other twin developing the disorder is quite small.'
Correct Answer: D

Rationale: The correct answer is D because it provides an accurate and sensitive response. Fraternal twins do not share the same genetic makeup as identical twins, so the genetic risk for the other twin developing schizophrenia is lower. By acknowledging this fact, the nurse offers reassurance to the mother without giving false hope or inaccurate statistics. This response shows understanding of the genetic component of schizophrenia and addresses the mother's concerns in a compassionate and informative manner.

Choices A, B, and C are incorrect:
A: This response is dismissive of the mother's concerns and does not provide any helpful information. It also lacks sensitivity and empathy towards the mother's situation.
B: This response provides an inaccurate statistic about the likelihood of the other twin developing schizophrenia. It does not consider the difference between identical and fraternal twins, leading to a potentially misleading statement.
C: This response is vague and does not address the mother's question directly. It does not provide any useful information or reassurance, leaving the mother uncertain and anxious about